Skip to main content
Riviera logo
On Air Now

1am to 4am

2am to 6am

Monaco's €209 million property dispute returns to Supreme Court amid fraud allegations

Monaco's Supreme Court is considering an unprecedented request to overturn two previous rulings in a long-running property dispute involving the Esplanade des Pêcheurs development at Port Hercule.

Share

Monaco's €209 million property dispute returns to Supreme Court amid fraud allegations
Monaco's €209 million property dispute returns to Supreme Court amid fraud allegations. Picture: Yury Kirillov/Alamy

By Camille Bidard

The Monegasque Government is seeking to cancel compensation awarded to developer Caroli Immo, now estimated at nearly €209 million including interest, following allegations of corruption and influence peddling linked to the original judgments.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The case returned to the Supreme Court on Tuesday, 3 November, with a decision expected on 18 November.

A dispute dating back to 2014

The legal battle began with a major property development agreement signed in 2014 between the Government and developer Antonio Caroli.

The project, planned for a 13,000-square-metre site at the entrance to Port Hercule, included residential properties, offices, shops and a museum dedicated to underwater archaeologist Franck Goddio's collections.

However, the Government abandoned the development in 2017, citing concerns about the space required for Formula 1 Grand Prix infrastructure.

The Supreme Court subsequently ruled against the State in 2018 and awarded Caroli Immo almost €137 million in compensation in 2020.

A revised, smaller development was later proposed, but the project faced further legal challenges and ultimately failed to progress.

With accumulated interest, the disputed compensation has now reached approximately €209 million.

Corruption allegations raise legal questions

The Government is challenging the original rulings following allegations involving former Supreme Court President Didier Linotte and Thierry Lacoste, a former lawyer to Prince Albert II.

Linotte was charged in June 2025 in connection with alleged corruption and conflicts of interest, while Lacoste was charged in September 2026 with alleged corruption and influence peddling.

Both contest the allegations and remain entitled to the presumption of innocence.

The Government argues that the suspected wrongdoing could justify overturning the court's previous decisions.

However, Monaco's legal framework does not currently provide a procedure for appealing final Supreme Court rulings, raising questions about whether such an exceptional review would be legally possible.

Caroli Immo's representatives oppose the request, arguing that reopening final judgments would undermine legal certainty.

Property developer Patrice Pastor has also joined the proceedings as a third party, supporting the State's position.

Meanwhile, Didier Linotte is seeking €500,000 in compensation for alleged damage to his reputation.

Decision expected on 18 November

During Tuesday's hearing, Prosecutor General Stéphane Thibault recommended postponing a decision on the Government's request until the parallel criminal proceedings have concluded.Such a delay could extend the dispute for several more years.

The case also has an international dimension, with Caroli Immo having taken its compensation dispute to the European Court of Human Rights.

The Supreme Court is expected to announce its decision on 18 November, potentially determining whether the Government can pursue its attempt to overturn the previous rulings.

The outcome could have significant financial consequences for the Principality, with nearly €209 million in disputed compensation at stake.